Two of the most stylish people in the world wore the same dress to an event, and fans aren’t sure who pulled off the look better. The internet is ablaze with debate over this topic.

Kendall Jenner and Selena Gomez were both seen wearing a stunning silver chainmail midi dress from the latest collection by designer LaQuan Smith. The metallic dress was slinky and had a high collar, long sleeves, and a thigh-high slit that showed off the stars’ toned legs.

Gomez first wore the stunning dress to the Los Angeles premiere of her Hulu series ‘Only Murders in the Building’ earlier this month. She paired it with a delicate butterfly necklace and black shoes for an outfit that felt like it was from the year 2000.

A few days later, Jenner wore the same dress to the Met Gala. For a more understated look, she paired it with simple black heels with straps and her typical smooth, slicked-back hairstyle.

The surprising fashion coincidence went viral right away on social media, with fans eager to share their opinions on which A-lister wore the shiny, futuristic look better.

“Selena wore this dress to the fullest; the butterfly necklace adds the perfect touch of nostalgia.” One Twitter user said, “Kendall looks great, but she didn’t bring the same level of personality.”

“I’m sorry, Kendall ate this all up.” The dress stands out because of how simple her outfit is. “Selena’s version is cool, but it seems a little too forced,” said another fan.

There were even people who said the two stars planned the dress showdown on purpose to get more attention.

“This could not have been an accident.” One cynical person thought, “Kendall and Selena are clearly trying to make this go viral and become a huge style debate.”

Even though there has been a lot of heated talk, Gomez and Jenner have kept quiet about the fashion fight and haven’t said who they thought wore the dress better.

No matter what, the surprising style overlap has made the slinky silver dress one of the most-wanted looks of the year so far. And the online fights between Selenators and Kendall fans show that the argument over who had the better chainmail dream is far from over.